I got this eyeliner during the kanebo sale. I simply like how the gel texture is. Its soft & smooth and easy to apply. It dries fast too. It comes with a retractable eyeliner brush. The brush is small and has a round tip which allows me to apply the gel very near to my lashes and it takes me less than a minute to line my lashes. The black color is intense just like the MAC fluid black track. Its a waterproof eyeliner so you need to use a waterproof makeup remover to remove it.